10 Ways to Enjoy Pumpkin Spice This Fall
We're going way beyond PSLs here, folks.
Sep 05, 2025
Ahh, fall. Temperatures are cooling, leaves are changing, and the most viral flavor combination is everywhere you look. That's right — it's pumpkin spice season.
Now, you may roll your eyes and claim that you are above this seemingly ubiquitous seasonal flavor and all the various forms in which it comes, but let's be honest: Pumpkin spice anything is delicious and worthy of your adoration. So, instead of turning up your nose, it's time to lean into pumpkin spice season and enjoy all the warm, cozy vibes it brings.
And the best part is, there are so many ways to get your fill of this signature autumn flavor. We're going way beyond lattes, with delightful pumpkin spice gifts and treats, and even floral displays that will make the comfy feel of the season linger long after the first snowfall.
Best pumpkin spice gifts for 2025
Here are the best ways to enjoy pumpkin spice this fall, whether you're treating yourself or the biggest PSL lover in your life.
It's the Great Pumpkin Basket
It's the Great Pumpkin Basket
Shop : Pumpkin-Shaped Gift Basket from Harry & David
Go all out with this jam-packed, pumpkin-themed gift crate. It's loaded with favorites like pumpkin-spiced cookies, pumpkin spice loaf cake, and a host of other delectable baked goods that celebrate the flavors of fall. This is the perfect gift for the person who just can't get enough pumpkin spice in their life.
Shop : Pumpkin-Shaped Gift Basket from Harry & David
Say Cheese!
Say Cheese!
Shop : Pumpkin Cheesecake from Harry & David
Cheesecake is a dessert that bridges the time on the calendar between when we eat refreshing chilled treats of summer and the heartier, denser desserts of fall and winter. So, naturally, a pumpkin spice cheesecake is always welcome this time of year. This beauty features layers of classic New York-style cheesecake with a limited-edition pumpkin cheesecake. A match made in dessert heaven.
Shop : Pumpkin Cheesecake from Harry & David
Give 'Em a Pound
Give 'Em a Pound
Shop : Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pound Cake Duo from Wolferman's Bakery
Your gluten-free friends (and even the gluten lovers in your life) will rejoice at the dense, moist texture and pumpkin-packed flavor of this pound cake. The loaves slice up nicely for sharing and are delicious for a sweet morning meal, an afternoon pick-me-up to pair with a cup of seasonal coffee, or late night snack.
Shop : Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pound Cake Duo from Wolferman's Bakery
Do Something Cin-Ful
Do Something Cin-Ful
Shop : Buttercream Frosted Cinnamon Pumpkin Cookie Flavor Box from Cheryl's Cookies
What's better on a fall afternoon than a soft, thick cookie smeared in a gently spiced buttercream frosting? Twelve soft, thick cookies smeared in a gently spiced buttercream frosting. These pumpkin cookies capture the flavors of fall in one sweet bite. If that's not enough, there's also a frosted pumpkin spice latte cookie. Go on! Double the pumpkin cookie goodness in your life. You won't regret it.
Shop : Buttercream Frosted Cinnamon Pumpkin Cookie Flavor Box from Cheryl's Cookies
Explore Nooks & Crannies
Explore Nooks & Crannies
Shop : Pumpkin Spice Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages from Wolferman's Bakery
Indulging in all things pumpkin spice doesn't have to mean a crazy sugar rush, and these airy and soft English muffins are proof. They're made with creamy pumpkin puree and signature fall spices, making them the ideal feature item in your autumnal breakfast. Try them toasted and slathered with plain butter, or go all autumn on these muffins with schmears of apple butter. Or, if you have a hankering for double pumpkin, then this is the butter for you. Insider tip: These muffins freeze beautifully, so stock up and enjoy pumpkin spice goodness all year long.
Shop : Pumpkin Spice Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages from Wolferman's Bakery
Butter Them Up
Butter Them Up
Shop : Pumpkin Butter from Harry & David
Speaking of breakfast toppings, outfit your fall morning spread with a jar of smooth and fluffy pumpkin butter to make everything from yogurt to oatmeal to pancakes taste like a coffeehouse delight. You can even cook with this pumpkin butter to add a seasonal flair to everything from cinnamon rolls to coffee cake to cheese plates.
Shop : Pumpkin Butter from Harry & David
Baskets With Spice
Baskets With Spice
Shop : Grand Harvest Sweets & Savories Gift Basket from 1-800-Baskets.com
Let's start this list off with a banger! Get your spice on with pumpkin spice Dolcetto wafer rolls, pumpkin spice popcorn, and a fall-themed chocolate-covered pretzel further covered in sprinkles in the shape of leaves. #adorbs. When the frost is on the pumpkin, warm up with a cup of maple bourbon coffee. And when you had your fill of fall treats, get down with more chocolate, toasted peanuts, and dried apricots.
Shop : Grand Harvest Sweets & Savories Gift Basket from 1-800-Baskets.com
Fall for Some Sweetness
Fall for Some Sweetness
A moist, delicious mini pumpkin cake. A generous topping of velvety cinnamon buttercream frosting. A snack-size, buttery-sweet snickerdoodle cookie. Put all that together and you get a completely irresistible fall treat that will delight the taste buds. These fall-flavored cupcakes, along with two each of chocolate and vanilla, come in a gorgeous box with illustrations of autumn foliage and pumpkins.
Mums the Word
Mums the Word
Here's a gift that allows you to savor the entire aesthetic of pumpkin spice. This long-lasting spray of burnt orange-colored mums is at home amid any holiday decor, and you can really amp up the autumn vibes by adding a pumpkin-spiced candle to these gorgeous seasonal flowers.
This Mug's for You!
This Mug's for You!
Teachers, parents, and any coffee/cocoa/tea drinker you know will love this cute, sweet, and practical gift set. It includes a pumpkin-shaped ceramic mug and a hot cocoa bomb, along with a selection of popular autumnal cookies, including a delicious buttercream-frosted pumpkin spice latte cookie.